Publications

26 March 2010
Compensation & Benefits , Tax law , Employment

Exceptional tax on bonuses paid by French banks and investment institutions (Corrective Finance Bill for 2010)

Stéphanie Le Men-Tenailleau

+33 (0)1 42 56 38 45

The French Parliament adopted on March 9 the Corrective Finance Bill for 2010, which creates an exceptional 50% tax on variable compensations paid to some of their employees by bank institutions.

The main characteristics of this tax, which is payable by French finance companies and investment institutions , are the following:

Beneficiaries of the bonuses

The tax applies on bonuses paid to employees who are financial markets professional « whose activities are likely to significantly influence the risk exposure of the company » and to the persons "under the control of which" the above defined employees perform their activities. The text does not mention the corporate officers but only employees meeting the above definition. The main issue will be to determine, for each company subject to the tax, the list of its employees falling into the scope of this particularly vague definition.

Basis of computation of the tax

The variable part of compensations referred to by the provisions of the Bill is defined as the gross amount of the compensation items paid to the abovementioned beneficiaries for their 2009 individual or collective results, including when the actual payment and vesting are conditional. Such variable part will be taken into account for the computation of the tax only for its portion exceeding EUR 27,500. Such compensation items are included in the basis of tax whatever the year of payment or of vesting would be. Consequently, as long as such compensation items would find, even partly, their source in activities performed in 2009, they will be subject to such tax, even in the event their actual payment would be deferred by one or several years. The only compensation items excluded from the scope of the Draft Bill would be the amounts paid with respect to legal compulsory and non-compulsory profit-sharing schemes, “Participation” and “Intéressement” (which are already subject to a 4% special tax, the “forfait social”).

Nature of the variable compensation items

The tax is computed to only on cash variable compensation items, but also on the ones granted through stock options, conditional share awards or any other share-based preferential awards. This tax applies even if the awards are granted by a foreign parent company or subsidiary. In case of grant of stock options or of conditional share awards, the tax is computed on the fair value of the options, shares or other securities, as defined for IFRS purposes (consolidated accounts). The computation basis is therefore identical as the one of the special employer’s contributions (for the above defined beneficiaries) payable on such awards by French employers. The tax is therefore likely in certain cases to be paid on compensation items which will never be actually paid out, in the event the applicable conditions provided for the vesting of the awards would not be met. Should this happen, the draft bill provides that no amount of tax shall be reimbursed.

Rate and payability date

The tax is due, at the rate of 50%, on the first day of the month following the grant decision. The tax will be declared and paid within twenty-five days of its payability date, using a form which will be issued by the French tax administration. The tax will be paid upon filing of the declaration. However, for bonuses paid before March 9, 2010, the tax will be payable as from April 1st, 2010, and before April 25, 2010.

This author's articles

16 May 2012

LEXCOM JOINS CELIA ALLIANCE

Comprised of independent law and professional services firms providing expert legal and tax services for human resources issues internationally, CELIA Alliance now has a correspondent in France through Lexcom.

8 April 2011
Compensation & Benefits , International Assignments

New withholding tax on share-option gains

The Amending Finance Bill for 2010 created a withholding tax which applies to profits made by non-residents on share-option gains, free shares and BSPCEs (stock warrants for business creators). But far from fulfilling the intention stated in parliament of “resolving the difficulties” of applying the existing law to this type of profits, the new withholding tax system proves to cause many technical contradictions and practical difficulties.

26 March 2010
Compensation & Benefits , International Assignments

Stock options and international assignments

Taxation of the gains derived from stock options in a cross-border context has been a debated question for several years on the international scene. However, France, unlike other European countries, has not yet taken a stand in this area. The French Supreme Administrative Court (“Conseil d’Etat”) has just partly settled the debate in a decision dated March 17, 2010, in accordance with the guidelines developed by the OECD since 2004.

8 February 2010
Compensation & Benefits , Employment

Stock-Options and termination for cause

The French Supreme Court confirmed for the first time, in a decision dated October 21, 2009 (n°08-42.026, Nebon-Carle c/ Sté Acxiom France), that section L. 1331-2 of the French labour code related to prohibited financial sanctions applies to stock-options.

21 September 2009
Compensation & Benefits , Tax law , Employment

Social security regime of the conventional termination indemnities and of "Golden parachutes"

Circular of the French social security direction dated July 10, 2009 in relation to the new social security treatment of some termination indemnities.

21 September 2009
Compensation & Benefits , Company Law

Regulated agreements and corporate officers’ compensation

Non approval of a regulated agreement by the Shareholders meeting does not trigger nullity of the agreement.

20 September 2009
Compensation & Benefits , Tax law , International Assignments

New impatriates regime: additional information

The French tax authorities published on July 30, 2009 a tax circular related to the impatriates regime, as amended by the law dated August 4, 2008. Here are the main additional information given by this circular.

Other Publications

Compensation & Benefits

New withholding tax on share-option gains

8 April 2011 - By Stéphanie Le Men-Tenailleau

The Amending Finance Bill for 2010 created a withholding tax which applies to profits made by non-residents on share-option gains, free shares and BSPCEs (stock warrants for business creators). (...)

Stock options and international assignments

26 March 2010 - By Stéphanie Le Men-Tenailleau

Taxation of the gains derived from stock options in a cross-border context has been a debated question for several years on the international scene. However, France, unlike other European (...)

Stock-Options and termination for cause

8 February 2010 - By Stéphanie Le Men-Tenailleau

The French Supreme Court confirmed for the first time, in a decision dated October 21, 2009 (n°08-42.026, Nebon-Carle c/ Sté Acxiom France), that section L. 1331-2 of the French labour code related (...)

Social security regime of the conventional termination indemnities and of "Golden parachutes"

21 September 2009 - By Stéphanie Le Men-Tenailleau

Circular of the French social security direction dated July 10, 2009 in relation to the new social security treatment of some termination indemnities.

Regulated agreements and corporate officers’ compensation

21 September 2009 - By Stéphanie Le Men-Tenailleau

Non approval of a regulated agreement by the Shareholders meeting does not trigger nullity of the agreement.

New impatriates regime: additional information

20 September 2009 - By Stéphanie Le Men-Tenailleau

The French tax authorities published on July 30, 2009 a tax circular related to the impatriates regime, as amended by the law dated August 4, 2008. Here are the main additional information given (...)

Tax law

Transfer tax in case of shares held in a foreign real estate entity

7 June 2010 - By

The French tax administration rules on the possible use of a credit for foreign taxes

VAT on services

28 September 2009 - By

VAT Directive implemented in France

Registration taxes

21 September 2009 - By

A transfer of shares may be recharacterized into a transfer of going business

Change in French business tax

21 September 2009 - By

Brief on French business tax to be replaced by a new tax so-called "Cotisation Economique Territoriale" (Draft Finance Bill for 2010)

Employment

The audit of the employer’s annual accounts upon request of the works council

26 January 2010 - By Nicolas Léger Loïc Héron

Two Supreme Court cases were issued on December 15, 2009 in relation to the prerogatives of the works council and the outside accountant they may appoint. The first case relates to the moment (...)